The story that won't die -- the media won't stop talking about Thomas Muthee, a native Kenyan and charismatic Christian minister who visited Wasilla, AK and prayed over Sarah Palin in 2005. A video of Muthee laying hands on Palin and praying over her has recently surfaced, and made headlines a few days ago. And check out this headline: "Palin affair claim, "witchcraft" blessing, dog McCain camp." There is no doubt in my mind that the press is desperately trying to find a Republican "Jeremiah Wright," some sort of fanatical preacher whom they can use to damage the Republican presidential ticket.
Rev. Thomas Muthee gained prominence in Kenya after he successfully rid his town of Mama Jane, who Muthee and scores of others believed to be a practitioner of black magic. Allegedly, Mama Jane was a sort of "godfather" to the town, with government and business officials afraid to do anything without her blessing. After prayer vigils and protests that eventually culminated in a police raid on her home, Mama Jane left the town of Kiambu, and Rev. Muthee publicly declared that he led his congregation to victory in a major spiritual warfare battle.
Rev. Muthee has been labeled by the press as a "witch-hunter," obviously in an effort to evoke images of the sham Salem Witch Trials of the 1690's. But here is why I don't think that Rev. Muthee will frighten average Americans to the extent that he has frightened the liberal chattering class. In the erudite United Church of Christ and Unitarian-Universalist congregations frequented by liberal elites, there is probably little mention of the forces of evil (unless, of course, they are talking about Republicans or the US military), but in fundamentalist evangelical protestant churches -- especially charismatic churches -- there is a very strong belief in spiritual forces of evil that are engaged in a continual effort to wreak havoc here on earth. The power of Satan over this world and his ability to destroy us are lessons taught regularly in American Sunday schools. Even though evangelicals differ with regard to their understanding of just how much we can be influenced by spiritual forces, millions upon millions of Americans still believe strongly in Satan and the power of evil.
In contrast, most Protestants and evangelicals would have a very difficult time understanding hardcore black liberation theology as taught by Rev. Jeremiah Wright. They would be mystified by BLT's understanding of sin as primarily a racial problem, and they would be perplexed and insulted at the direct blame for the current state of our world that BLT assigns explicitly to the arrogance and bigotry of the white ruling class. However, liberal UCC and UU members would probably have an easy time understanding BLT and associating it with progressive teachings about class struggle and racial injustice.
The majority of white evangelicals would find BLT offensive, while liberal UCC and UU'ers would have little objection to it. On the other hand, evangelicals can understand Rev. Muthee's belief in the power of Satan, while such talk would seem shockingly primitive and dangerous to progressives. That's the primary difference between Rev. Muthee and Rev. Jeremiah Wright.
Even though most evangelicals probably don't share Rev. Muthee's very strong belief in the occult and in the power of sorcery and witchcraft (he is, after all, from continental Africa, where belief in the occult is still very strong) they would not object to his sincere prayers for Sarah Palin, or to his sincere desire that she be kept out of harm's way (including supernatural harm) and that she prosper in her career as a politician.